|
|
Ye had online and white, Shen Haobo, Lu Chuan, Accidental,http://gracebrasil.org.br/cache/fgktkutppv.html, Liu Qian, Han Han people fought battle pen, during the Dragon Chinese New Year hit with extensive experience in terms of playing pen battle after Fang,http://www.hoettcke-holz.de/cache/chznpgpwsd.html, chose from the Internet to reality. Han said in a statement to sue Fang in Shanghai, claims loss of reputation 100,http://www.3y2.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=670044,000 yuan, while Fang said that they would actively responding. However, legal experts say, between the case in time to be sub-contracting, Han Fang sued the odds are not too great.
The latest progress
Han
Claims 100,000
Yesterday, Han partner, publisher Lu Jinbo allegedly, between January 19 to January 28 date, Fang microblogging continuously published "acting in Han," "History and the level of genius Han",http://aggeusz.pl/library/eqdohntlzf.html, "Han's reward farce "and other articles, and forwarded the article reviews a number of others, clearly pointed out that Han works" ghostwriter "," water army packaging "a great impact on the network.
Lu Jinbo said,http://www.wvs-ostrowski.de/cache/jvmojkikdf.html, in order to confirm the creation of works of their own hands,http://www.erta.at/data/mskkialexo.html, Han yourself finishing the manuscript between 1997-2000, the communication, the material in this and other information, a total of approximately 1000. These data will be notarized and authenticity forensic, identification year including paper, Han's handwriting. Han believes this information is sufficient to prove that "doctor", "book", "cup peep" and "triple gate" and so are their own independent creation. Meanwhile Han evidence to prove that the process of writing an essay contest and participate in the new concept of no ghostwriter and cheating.
Lu Jinbo said that, given Fang questioning process, repeatedly distorted the facts, repeated misleading inference, drawn with the real situation is completely the opposite conclusion, and wantonly spread, constitute Han reputation and serious violations of property rights, Han court proceedings will be required to correct Fang public apology, compensation for economic loss of 100,000 yuan.
Han yesterday also released a new blog "I wrote these can become evidence in court," the text for yourself why did not direct the court to sue each other, earlier articles are written by the father on behalf of, why not in a TV interview as well as new concepts essay contest Why cloth when the paper written to answer eight questions.
Fang
Not seriously
Han said after the party would take legal proceedings Fang, Fang said not to prosecute seriously, will not appear in court, but by a lawyer respondent.
Fang think they did not infringe the right of reputation Han, Han signed and will continue to analyze the article. Fang while Bowen, Han and his father's response to comments and continue to question Han's article and there are many self-contradictory statement, insisting that Han early "bookstore",http://gracebrasil.org.br/cache/fsidodzbat.html, "doctor" and other articles is certainly not the Han I written, by gunmen suspected to write.
In addition, it has been learned that he will apologize cornfield after being indicted, questioned said it has apologized, Han also accepted the apology, and now have to sue,http://115.29.44.191/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=640504, this is speculation. Catcher said that if the court accepts, he will be actively responding and counterclaims,http://enjoy1.bb-east.ne.jp/~sky-tears/cgi-bin/apeboard_plus.cgi?command=v/, not reconciliation! Catcher also said that he will re-questioned Han.
Our reporter Wang Run
Expert analysis
Hit counterfeiting expert, Han dilemma
For he would be taken to court, Fang believes that his analysis of the signed article Han, questioning, criticizing, is freedom of speech and academic criticism, while Han and his team for his attack alleged violations of the right of reputation. He said: "The verdict of the Court whether or not in my favor, I do not think it will affect my analysis conclusions are not set up for me to continue to analyze litigation Han signed articles have any effect.."
"Fang itself is a fake master, and such a crafty opponent put right, had at the time and Lu Chuan, who played Han pen capability to battle a bit amateurish, the dilemma." Beijing Guang Heng Law Office Zhaosan Ping analysis, social influence Fang big, "Fang powder" is also a lot through the microblogging and blog their disposal is also important component of the right to speak, he came out to question Han influence than some previous question were much more . And Fang is also more shrewd, such as he himself does not directly write "Han impossible to write such an article to the age of 17," he will first be forwarded to other people, then their own micro-blog, and then be reviewed, with their own influence enlarge its effect.
And Han prosecution to have much impact on the Fang? Zhaosan Ping lawyers believe minimal. First, Fang has responded that he lost 100,000 yuan for nothing impacts; Secondly, Xiao Fang was sued in Wuhan, the results of Fang loses, the court also deducted from the account to go a few million, but did not prevent him from continue to question Xiao.
Han reward effective,http://dsycyw.com/thread-602483-1-1.html, Fang infringement TBD
January 16, Han said in a blog: "If anyone can prove that they ghostwriter to write articles for me, even if his words had only ghostwriter,http://www.z-tech.jp/bbs1/sunbbs.cgi?mode=form&no=9545&page=1;., ever received any media belong 'Han' team 'or from I published a press release request propaganda, were rewarded 20 million yuan. "
Fang Han in the report which will be informed after the court, joked that this is someone collecting evidence ghostwriter Han reward, he was issued a document looking for evidence, the results of anti was Han court.
Zhaosan Ping lawyer analysts say, publicly reward Han is a contract offer, reward performance in content, the obligation and the amount of reward, is a legitimate offer. And since then against Han Fang questioned, it is by finding some doubt, really trying to get someone to give him Han admitted ghostwriter.
However, lawyers believe Zhaosan Ping Fang whether the infringement, is liable without sentenced in between. From the text, the Fang no obvious insulting language, but he is also more seasoned, some words are forwarded microblogging others.
From the perspective of literary criticism,http://clp.biz.pl/clone/ylfbmcoygs.html, insulting language does not necessarily have to constitute defamation. For a writer, questioned his article was not written by him, is someone doing it itself is the biggest insult to this writer. In the absence of evidence,http://w11.s54.xrea.com/navi/aska.cgi, this question has exceeded the normal range of literary criticism. Zhaosan Ping, said Han and Fang's lawsuit, now use computers for writing writers, but also a warning, the old writers can use the previous document as evidence, new writers how to prove the article on the computer is their own creation ?
Our reporter Yang Changping
Event Review
January 15 well-known blogger Catcher Bowen "artificial Han," said Han entirely by his father and publisher of the "packaging."
January 16 Han Han denies any team or individual ghostwriter, offering a reward of 20 million reward to any person to provide ghostwriter evidence, such as true the last novel.
January 18 Fang taking over "fake." On the same day, Catcher issued a letter of apology. That night,http://clp.biz.pl/clone/ihuiqmehag.html, Fang responded Catcher apologize,http://aggeusz.pl/library/fvhrnwcwxf.html, said had nothing to do,http://www.comundo.eu/info/uemnrvlugx.html, continue to question.
January 19 Japan and South Korea the third cold response that accept the "wheat" apology. And published "artificial Fang",http://www.grobelny-pleszew.com.pl/table/rvfqtuwgik.html,http://ensembleada.com/publicity_next12/sunbbs.cgi?mode=form&, accusing Fang exist "five sins."
January 21 to 23 hair blog questioned Hanhan Wen Fang history level and the "triple gate" title to read law.
January 25 Korean cold hair blog showcasing its "triple gate" manuscript map, and decided to compiled and published. On the same day, Fang Han participate in the process of publishing a new blog questioned the concept essay contest.
January 26 Fang has questioned the "triple gate" by Han father ghostwriter,http://www.gotrues.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=184188,http://www.bitax.si/cache/tvfdxhtzxp.html, concurrent blog analysis Han works "doctor."
January 27 to 28, Han Han and his father issued continuously introduce Korean father and his work.
January 29 against Lu Jinbo said Han will be prosecuted, Fang said, "Welcome to the prosecution." |
|